As Keir Starmer enters 2025, the weight of his first six months as Prime Minister is apparent. The optimism that often accompanies a new leader has been replaced by mounting challenges and growing scrutiny. Far from basking in a honeymoon period, Starmer’s tenure has been marked by tough decisions, public dissatisfaction, and a Cabinet struggling to find its footing.
A Prime Minister Under Pressure
Starmer’s demeanor has shifted, with critics noting a sense of frustration in his public appearances. His winter break in Madeira was seen by many as an opportunity to recharge and reset, but the path ahead remains steep. A recent Deltapoll survey underscores the uphill battle, with 69% of respondents believing the country is headed in the wrong direction and only 18% expressing optimism. Such numbers are a stark warning for any government, let alone one still trying to establish its footing.
Labour insiders express concern over a series of unforced errors that have marred Starmer's administration. From policy missteps to communication failures, these issues have left many questioning the government’s ability to deliver on its promises. Some of the harshest criticism has been directed at Chancellor Rachel Reeves, whose policies have sparked frustration within the party. Labour MPs privately lament the absence of seasoned advisors, as decisions are increasingly driven by inexperienced aides.
The Cabinet’s Role in Starmer’s Future
As 2025 unfolds, Starmer’s fate may hinge on the performance of his Cabinet. Figures like Wes Streeting, the Health Secretary, stand out as capable and action-oriented, but even his initiatives have faced skepticism. His recent announcement of an independent commission on social care, set to report in 2028, has been criticized as a delay tactic when immediate action is needed. The crisis in social care demands decisive leadership, not prolonged deliberation.
Other Cabinet members face equally pressing challenges. The handling of the child grooming scandal, which has resurfaced in national discourse, poses significant risks. Jess Phillips, the safeguarding minister, has faced backlash for her refusal to commit to a comprehensive inquiry. Starmer’s own record on the issue, dating back to his time as Director of Public Prosecutions, is under scrutiny, with critics questioning whether he has taken accountability seriously.
Key Issues to Address
For Starmer, the mistakes of 2024 must not be repeated. Voters are demanding transparency and effectiveness in governance. Key areas requiring immediate attention include:
- Tax Policy: Starmer’s government has faced criticism for tax hikes without clear economic benefits. Moving forward, any proposed increases must be accompanied by detailed explanations of how they will stimulate growth.
- NHS Spending: The allocation of £22 billion to the NHS without guarantees of measurable improvements has drawn ire. A more results-oriented approach is essential to restore public confidence.
- Regulatory Reform: Calls for new quangos and increased regulation have been met with resistance. Streamlining government operations and reducing bureaucracy could help rebuild trust.
Starmer’s approach to economic growth also raises questions. Recent appeals to regulators for ideas on boosting the economy have been seen as ironic, given the government’s role in shaping regulatory frameworks. Critics argue that Starmer must lead with a clearer vision and bolder strategies.
The Stakes for 2025
The year ahead is undeniably make-or-break for Starmer. His approval ratings have reached new lows, and one-third of voters believe he won’t last the year as Prime Minister. Meanwhile, political opponents like Nigel Farage are watching closely, ready to capitalize on Labour’s missteps.
To secure a second term, Starmer must focus on delivering tangible results, improving communication with the public, and uniting his party. The clock is ticking, and the challenges are immense, but the opportunity to turn things around remains.